We Talk About Values. Why Don’t We Examine What Actually Gets Rewarded?
An organisation’s culture isn’t just reflected in the behaviours it encourages. It’s revealed in the behaviours it tolerates, recognises and rewards.
Ask most organisations what kind of culture they’re trying to create and you’ll hear familiar ambitions.
Collaboration. Accountability. Innovation. Integrity. Respect.
These are all reasonable things to aspire to.
And organisations invest considerable effort defining what they mean, communicating them and encouraging employees to demonstrate them.
But there’s a question that often gets overlooked.
What actually gets rewarded around here?
Because the answer isn’t always the same as what’s written on the wall.
The difference between what we say and what we reinforce
Imagine an organisation that promotes collaboration as one of its core values.
Employees are encouraged to share knowledge, work across teams and support one another.
But when performance reviews arrive, recognition goes almost exclusively to individual achievements.
The person who delivers their targets independently gets celebrated.
The person who spends time helping others succeed gets thanked, but their contribution rarely influences how performance is assessed.
Neither approach is necessarily intentional.
But the message is clear.
Collaboration is encouraged.
Individual performance is rewarded.
Now imagine a business that champions innovation.
Leaders encourage employees to challenge conventions, experiment and explore new ideas.
But when an experiment fails, the conversation quickly turns to who approved it and why it didn’t work.
People learn something from that experience.
Just not necessarily what the organisation intended.
Culture follows consequences
We often treat culture as something we can influence primarily through communication.
We launch values. We create behavioural frameworks. We run workshops and ask leaders to role-model what good looks like.
These activities can be useful.
But they compete with something much more immediate.
The consequences people experience when they behave in particular ways.
- What happens when someone challenges a senior leader?
- What happens when a team misses a target because it prioritised quality?
- What happens when someone admits they made a mistake?
- What happens when an employee delivers outstanding results while treating colleagues poorly?
The answers tell people what the organisation really values.
Not necessarily because anyone has explicitly said so, but because people learn from what they see.
The systems behind the behaviour
This is why culture work can’t stop at defining desirable behaviours.
It needs to examine the environment in which those behaviours are expected to happen.
Consider the connection between values and everyday organisational practices.
- Performance management: Are people assessed on how they achieve results, or only what they deliver?
- Recognition: Which contributions receive attention and appreciation?
- Promotion: What behaviours help people progress?
- Decision-making: Are employees genuinely empowered, or are decisions consistently escalated?
- Leadership: What happens when senior people contradict the behaviours expected of everyone else?
These aren’t separate from culture.
They’re part of how culture operates.
And when they contradict the stated values, employees are left to decide which message to believe.
Usually, the one with the most immediate consequences wins.
The danger of rewarding the wrong thing
There’s another dimension worth considering.
Sometimes organisations don’t simply fail to reward the behaviours they want.
They actively reward behaviours that undermine them.
A leader who consistently delivers commercial results might be celebrated despite creating an environment where people are afraid to challenge them.
An employee who works excessive hours might be recognised for their commitment, even while the organisation promotes sustainable working.
A team that bypasses processes to meet a deadline might be praised for its agility, despite creating problems elsewhere.
Over time, these examples establish expectations.
People observe what success looks like and adjust their behaviour.
The organisation may continue talking about its values.
But employees are learning a different set of rules.
From defining values to testing them
None of this means organisations should abandon values.
It means values need to be examined against reality.
Rather than asking only whether employees understand the values, we could ask:
- Where do our systems make it easier to demonstrate them?
- Where do our processes make them harder to practise?
- Which behaviours are we rewarding that contradict what we say matters?
- What are leaders doing that sends a different message?
These questions move culture from aspiration into application.
They also create a more useful conversation about the changes required to make the desired behaviours possible.
Culture is what the organisation reinforces
The most meaningful culture work doesn’t simply describe how people should behave.
It examines what encourages, enables and discourages those behaviours.
Because you can ask people to collaborate, but reward competition.
You can encourage innovation, but punish failure.
You can promote accountability, but avoid difficult conversations.
And you can talk about respect while overlooking the behaviour of your highest performers.
We spend time defining the behaviours we want. Perhaps we should spend just as much time examining the behaviours we reward.
Something to try
Take one of your organisation’s most important values.
Now identify three recent examples of people being recognised, promoted or rewarded.
Ask yourself:
Did those decisions reinforce the value, contradict it or have no clear connection to it?
The answer might reveal more about your culture than your latest values campaign.