We Promise Candidates Opportunity. Why Don’t We Examine What Happens When They Join?
The employee value proposition might attract someone to your organisation. Their everyday experience determines whether that promise holds up.
There’s a lot of effort involved in convincing someone to join an organisation.
We develop employer brands, refine employee value propositions, improve careers websites and create compelling recruitment campaigns.
We talk about development opportunities, supportive leadership, meaningful work and the chance to make an impact.
And rightly so.
People deserve to understand what an organisation can offer them.
But there’s something worth questioning.
How much effort do we put into making sure those promises become reality?
The promise before the experience
Imagine a candidate exploring two potential employers.
One offers a clear story about professional growth.
Its careers website features employees talking about development, progression and the opportunities they’ve been given.
The interview reinforces that message.
The candidate joins, excited about what lies ahead.
Three months later, they’re still waiting for a meaningful development conversation.
Their manager is supportive but overwhelmed. Learning opportunities exist, but accessing them is complicated. Career progression is discussed, although nobody seems entirely clear about how it works.
Nothing in the recruitment campaign was necessarily false.
But the experience hasn’t matched the expectation.
And that gap matters.
Attraction and retention aren’t separate conversations
Employer branding is often treated as an attraction activity.
Its success is measured through applications, candidate engagement, careers website traffic and recruitment outcomes.
These are useful measures.
But they only tell us part of the story.
An employer brand doesn’t stop influencing someone when they accept an offer.
The expectations it creates follow them into the organisation.
Every promise about development, flexibility, leadership and culture becomes something the employee can compare with their experience.
The more compelling the promise, the more important it becomes to deliver it.
This creates an interesting challenge.
An employer brand can be highly effective at attracting candidates while simultaneously creating expectations the organisation struggles to meet.
In that situation, better attraction isn’t necessarily the answer.
Greater alignment is.
The danger of a polished promise
Most organisations don’t deliberately set out to mislead candidates.
The gap often emerges because the people developing the employer brand aren’t always responsible for delivering the employee experience.
Recruitment teams focus on attracting talent.
HR teams develop policies and programmes.
Managers shape the everyday experience.
Leaders make decisions about investment, priorities and ways of working.
Each plays a part in the promise.
But unless those parts are connected, the story candidates hear can become disconnected from the reality employees encounter.
Consider a few common examples.
- An organisation promises autonomy, but new starters encounter layers of approval.
- It promotes career development, but managers lack the time or tools to support it.
- It celebrates flexibility, but individual teams apply very different expectations.
- It highlights collaboration, but performance incentives encourage internal competition.
The problem isn’t necessarily the message itself.
It’s the distance between the message and the mechanisms required to deliver it.
What if we measured promise fulfilment?
Rather than measuring only how effectively the employer brand attracts people, what if we also examined whether the expectations it creates are being met?
Imagine asking employees at 30, 90 and 180 days:
- What attracted you to join us?
- Which expectations have been met?
- Which expectations haven’t matched your experience?
- What’s surprised you most about working here?
The answers could reveal where the employer brand is accurate, where the experience is inconsistent and where the organisation needs to improve.
They could also strengthen future recruitment messaging.
Because the most credible employer brand isn’t necessarily the one with the most compelling language.
It’s the one employees recognise as true.
Better employer branding starts with better understanding
This is why the strongest employee value propositions should be grounded in research.
Not just what leaders believe the organisation offers.
Not just what the business wants to be known for.
But what employees genuinely experience, value and believe makes the organisation distinctive.
That doesn’t mean every aspect of the employee experience needs to be perfect.
Candidates don’t expect perfection.
They do, however, deserve an accurate understanding of what they’re joining.
And organisations benefit when the people they attract have expectations that align with the reality of working there.
The real test of an employer brand
An employer brand shouldn’t simply help people choose to join.
It should help the right people make an informed choice and give them reasons to stay.
That requires a closer connection between the promise made during recruitment and the experience delivered afterwards.
We measure how well our employer brand attracts people. Perhaps we should measure how well the organisation delivers what attracted them.
Something to try
Ask five recent joiners one question:
What’s the biggest difference between what you expected before joining and what you’ve experienced since?
Don’t limit the conversation to disappointments.
Positive surprises are just as valuable.
Both can help you create an employer brand that’s not only attractive, but credible.