We Measure Customer Satisfaction. Why Don’t We Measure What Makes Good Service Difficult?
Customer experience isn’t only shaped by what employees are willing to do. It’s shaped by what the organisation makes possible.
Businesses invest heavily in understanding how customers feel.
We measure satisfaction, loyalty, advocacy and the likelihood that someone will recommend us.
We collect feedback, monitor complaints and analyse the moments that matter across the customer journey.
All important activities.
But there’s another side to the experience that deserves just as much attention.
How easy are we making it for employees to deliver the service we expect?
The experience customers don’t see
Imagine a customer contacting a business with a relatively straightforward request.
The employee helping them is knowledgeable, friendly and genuinely wants to resolve the issue.
But the information they need sits across three different systems.
One requires a separate login.
Another contains outdated information.
And the final decision needs approval from someone who isn’t available.
The employee apologises, puts the customer on hold and starts navigating the process.
From the customer’s perspective, the service feels slow and frustrating.
From the employee’s perspective, they’re doing everything they can.
The problem isn’t necessarily the person delivering the service.
It’s the environment they’re delivering it within.
When service expectations meet operational reality
Many organisations invest in customer service training.
They teach employees to listen, show empathy, take ownership and resolve problems.
These are valuable capabilities.
But training alone can’t overcome every obstacle.
You can teach someone to take ownership, but if they have no authority to make a decision, ownership becomes difficult to demonstrate.
You can encourage employees to make every interaction personal, but if systems don’t provide the information they need, personalisation becomes harder.
You can ask people to resolve problems quickly, but if processes require multiple handovers, speed becomes difficult to achieve.
The organisation has created an expectation.
Its operating environment may be making that expectation harder to fulfil.
The hidden cost of workarounds
Employees are often remarkably resourceful.
They develop shortcuts, maintain their own records, build relationships with colleagues who can unblock decisions and find ways to deliver despite inefficient processes.
Sometimes these workarounds become so established that nobody questions them.
They simply become part of how things get done.
But there’s a risk.
When employees consistently compensate for broken processes, the organisation can underestimate the problem.
Customers may still receive acceptable service.
Performance targets may still be met.
Managers may see little reason to investigate.
Meanwhile, employees are spending unnecessary time and effort delivering an experience that should be easier to provide.
And when the person who knows the workaround leaves, the problem becomes visible again.
What if we measured service friction?
Customer feedback tells us how the experience was received.
Employee feedback can help explain why the experience happened.
Both perspectives matter.
Alongside customer satisfaction, organisations could explore questions such as:
- Which customer requests are hardest to resolve, and why?
- Where do employees have to repeat information or duplicate work?
- Which decisions require unnecessary escalation?
- What prevents employees from delivering the service standards we expect?
- Where are employees relying on workarounds to keep the experience running?
These questions can reveal operational problems that traditional customer feedback might not identify.
They also create an opportunity to improve the experience for customers and employees at the same time.
Better service isn’t always about better training
When customer satisfaction declines, the instinct is often to focus on frontline performance.
Perhaps employees need more training.
Perhaps managers need to reinforce service standards.
Perhaps the business needs a renewed focus on customer centricity.
Sometimes those responses are appropriate.
But sometimes the issue sits elsewhere.
In systems.
In policies.
In decision-making.
In staffing models.
In the gap between what the business asks people to deliver and what it enables them to do.
Before introducing another training programme, it might be worth understanding whether employees already know what good looks like but struggle to deliver it.
Because improving capability and removing obstacles are two different interventions.
And they solve different problems.
The connection between employee and customer experience
Customer experience and employee experience are often managed as separate disciplines.
But the two meet every day in the moments when employees deliver a product, service or interaction.
The systems employees use, the decisions they’re allowed to make and the support they receive all influence what customers experience.
That doesn’t mean every employee frustration automatically becomes a customer problem.
But it does mean that understanding customer experience without examining the conditions behind its delivery can leave important questions unanswered.
We measure whether customers are satisfied with the experience. Perhaps we should also measure how difficult we make that experience to deliver.
Something to try
Choose one common customer request.
Follow it from the moment the customer makes contact to the moment the issue is resolved.
Then ask the employees involved:
What made that harder than it needed to be?
The answer might reveal an improvement that benefits both your customers and your people.